Can the UK achieve energy sustainability with Wind and Photovoltaic energy?

Can the UK achieve energy sustainability with Wind and Photovoltaic energy generation technology?

Dr Richard Curry, Research Programme Manager at the SUSTAIN, doesn’t think that we can.

Cheap, readily available electrical and chemical energy has been the cornerstone of many, if not all, of the technological and social advancements of the last century. It has also made provision for cheap transport, domestic energy and plentiful cheap food. The pressure of climate change and the global treaties to reduce CO2 from industrial nations has encouraged the move towards technologies such as photovoltaics (PV) and wind-turbines, with outsourcing of oil & gas production and refining.

In Europe and the UK we are entering a serious energy crisis. Over-reliance upon global supply chains for fossil fuels, closure of petrochemical refineries and coal- and gas-fired power stations without equivalent robust replacement has left the UK exposed to soaring energy prices and potential shortages in the future.

“Are we blindly hoping that technologies that may not be ready to meet our fundamental needs will solve the problem?”

Fear of climate change accountability from the Government and general public has led to a reluctance to mine remaining domestic coal and oil resources at a time when cheap energy is essential to make the switch to renewable energy. Instead, the recent focus has been on outsourcing, which imparts a negative carbon burden globally. International reliance upon fossil fuels can be shown to provide a short term economic benefit due to the lower operational costs of other nations, but from an environmental and ecological perspective, due to the need for transport and less stringent mining conditions, the global situation can be shown to be overall negative. Furthermore, the security of supply and control of cost can be lost when one considers the stability of the supplying nations in terms of their relationship with their neighbours, Europe and the US. Recent global crises have exposed this risk and have exacerbated an already difficult situation within the UK.

Wind and photovoltaic energy generation image via Adobe Stock

In 2018, the UK Government announced its achievements on meeting and exceeding the Kyoto Target. However, this has been almost wholly achieved by the decimation of UK industry in the face of cheap imports, effectively outsourcing the carbon to less developed nations with the added fuel burden of transport, job losses and financial value to the circulating internal UK economy.

The effects of the industrial demise can be seen in Figure 1 below, in terms of UK industrial power consumption now being equivalent to services. In addition to lowering the nation’s energy requirements, this has also led to a drop in sovereign capability and severely hollowed out supply chains for the industry that remains.

Figure 1: Change in energy consumption in the UK between 1970 and 2019. (Source: UK Government report on Energy Consumption in the UK (1970-2019), 2020)

As energy prices rise we see proportional rises in commodity and transport costs. The consumer, including academic and industrial sector research, will ultimately pay the higher cost without equivalent increase in funding leading to far less progress for the pound.

The UK’s 2019 average yearly power requirement for both industry and domestic of 140m tonnes of oil equivalent (toe) (see UK Government report on Energy Consumption in the UK (1970-2020), 2021). The agreed conversion rate is 1 toe = 12mWh giving 1680tWh.

The global strategy, which includes the UK, has been to champion renewable energy from wind farms and PV as a direct replacement. Modern wind farm turbines can output 2.2MWh (120m turbine diameter) and require a minimum turbine to turbine spacing of at least 360m x 840m, side by side and proximity in the direction of the prevailing wind respectively.

Following a simple calculation using these figures, this would result in 750 million wind turbines with over 200 million km2 of area required. Given that the UK is not much larger than 220,000 km2 and the earth’s area is approximately 500 million km2, we seem to have a fundamental global issue in terms of energy density. Add to this the reduced efficiency from available wind energy, both in terms of day to day and seasonal variation, the available power will drop further requiring more turbines; recent concern over wind farm efficiency has prompted calls for turbine spacing to be increased up to 15x rotor diameter. Also, to meet the peak energy needs of the country during the winter months an efficient, yet undecided storage method is required.

Photovoltaic energy farm
Photovoltaic power generation image via Unsplash

Moving to PV, which have an energy density of up to 230 kWh/m2 we can make a direct comparison with turbines which from the previous numbers becomes 7.3 Wh/m2. Although the apparent energy density of photovoltaics is much higher, one needs to remember that this number will reduce significantly once the operational conditions are considered. In the UK and Western Europe, the strength of the received solar energy is sub optimal and further reduced by cloud and seasonal daylight variation. Even if a constant 230 kWh/m2 were possible, again an area well over 7000 km2 would be required, which is >3% of the UK’s land mass.

On a more positive note, the 2.2MWh turbine only requires 1400t (900t if fully recycled after use) of CO2 to produce energy over a 20-25yr lifespan. Compared to natural gas, the UKs leading power and heating fuel, which emits 408kgCO2/MWh. Over 25 years this would result in 89mt of emitted CO2, several orders of magnitude greater than the initial level required to manufacture an equivalent turbine.

Wind turbines also recoup the energy used to manufacture within 1-2 years, which is on par with the latest figures for PV that, according to NREL of the US Department of Energy, can range from 1 to 3 years. In a country like the UK, this equates to up to 6 years due to the lower light levels.

Some thin film and printable PV solutions are showing vast improvements in this figure but still require significant research and energy to mature. Unfortunately, many of the elements used in the manufacture of PV technologies and the by-products from refining them, are in themselves highly toxic and can be shown to have a highly negative effect upon the environment, especially when cost effective processing methods are used.

The location that the PV units are manufactured is also significant, with Chinese products having a much higher carbon debt due to the manufacturing energy coming from predominantly coal fired power stations, rather than the mixed, semi-renewable status of Europe.

It is clear that we must ensure that a transition to green energy is supported by a suitable legacy fuel source to ensure that the lights don’t go out domestically and industrially. Jumping to an infeasible or immature technology too early will significantly disrupt industry, consumers and our current standard of living. It will also retard progress in the development of truly sustainable green technologies and result in a far lengthier R&D journey accruing equivalent or higher CO2 emissions over the period than if the emissions were compressed to provide our energy requirements over the short term.

An artist’s impression of the Rolls-Royce Small Modular Reactor

A technology such as nuclear may need more serious consideration, as it is already commercially developed but not deployed effectively due to recent heightening of fear following the Fukushima disaster and the devastating environmental / ecological risk when these plants have issues. A situation where the UK cannot sustain its industrial and domestic energy needs, with energy prices contributing significantly to uncontrolled inflation, is not an option.

Are we blindly hoping that technologies that may not be ready to meet our fundamental needs will solve the problem?

We do need to begin somewhere, but eliminating established methods of energy production, such as fossil fuels and nuclear without proof that the new technologies will achieve the required goal will only result in a negative outcome: both economically and environmentally.

To find out more about his work and experience, you can read Dr Richard Curry’s profile on the SUSTAIN website, connect with Dr Richard Curry on LinkedIn, and find out more about the SUSTAIN programme by visiting their website:

About the author

Latest articles

Featured article
  • Women with Metal

    Women with Metal

    It’s been 7 weeks since the first Women with Metal event and the 2nd edition of this sell out conference has already been booked top take place on 29 October 2024. Kirsty is increasing the size and scale of the event and has booked a hall at the ICC Birmingham for year 2 with the…

    Read article →

  • Organized Crime Drives Metal Theft Epidemic: UK Economy Loses Half a Billion Annually.

    Organized Crime Drives Metal Theft Epidemic: UK Economy Loses Half a Billion Annually.

    A newly released report by the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Metal, Stone, and Heritage reveals that metal theft orchestrated by organized crime groups is costing the UK economy a staggering half a billion pounds each year. The comprehensive study, titled “Tackling Metal Theft,” exposes a rising trend in metal-related crimes since 2019, amounting to a…

    Read article →

  • Van Leeuwen: The Energy Project

    Van Leeuwen: The Energy Project

    In December 2021 Jill Clements told me about the Energy Project that had been signed off by Van Leeuwen UK. Jill was animated when talking about the news, and excitedly explained the potential that this opened up to her and the team. “I am very excited about it. I am really happy that finally we…

    Read article →

  • Drywall Steel Sections Secures £9.5 Million WMCA Investment

    Drywall Steel Sections Secures £9.5 Million WMCA Investment

    £13 million was all it took for a family run manufacturing business to make a monumental transformation in the historic heart of the steel industry! Drywall Steel Sections Ltd are on the move after securing loan funding of £9.5 million from the West Midlands Combined Authority (WMCA). Their Cradley Heath site was no longer fit…

    Read article →

  • The NASS Golf day & Summer Gathering 2023

    The NASS Golf day & Summer Gathering 2023

    On the 29th of June, Matt Tipper, Stewart Andrews and I had a swing of the clubs at Priory Breadsall in Derby. A week later, on the 6th of July, I attended the Summer Gathering in central Birmingham. Two entirely different events, seven days apart, both hosted by The National Association of Steel Service Centres…

    Read article →

  • The Stainless Steel Industry Meets at the BSSA Annual Conference & Dinner

    The Stainless Steel Industry Meets at the BSSA Annual Conference & Dinner

    The British Stainless Steel Association (BSSA) met at The Grand Hotel in Birmingham in May 2023 for their annual conference and dinner. Having attended the last four BSSA annual conferences and this year’s Food and Beverage Industry event (link to article), it was great to catch up with familiar faces from the industry and new…

    Read article →

  • Q2 Review: Analysing The Recruitment Landscape

    Q2 Review: Analysing The Recruitment Landscape

    Large corporate companies are facing challenges attracting new talent and retaining skilled staff especially when their salary structures, work flexibility and staff benefits are outdated compared to smaller, more agile SMEs. Smaller companies can have the advantage of being able to offer more flexibility and quicker decision-making, meaning they’re a more appealing option for certain…

    Read article →

  • How to use LinkedIn for YOUR Metal Business.

    How to use LinkedIn for YOUR Metal Business.

    The below presentation was given at the National Association of Steel Service Centres (NASS) 2023 Summer Gathering. In 12 days I’ll have been using LinkedIn for 12 years! On the day I joined I thought: “Wow! This business Facebook thingy is incredible! Everyone I want to do business with is right here, this will be…

    Read article →

  • Leading the Charge: Steel Dynamics in the Nuclear Industry

    Leading the Charge: Steel Dynamics in the Nuclear Industry

    Prime Minister Rishi Sunak recently unveiled the Great British Nuclear initiative, marking a significant milestone in the UK’s pursuit of a sustainable energy future. With nuclear power playing a crucialrole in achieving net-zero emissions and reducing greenhouse gases, this announcement signals a remarkable leap forward in the nation’s commitment to clean and reliable energy sources.…

    Read article →

  • Steel Dynamics Group Ltd. Acquires Ferrari Stainless & Alloys.

    Steel Dynamics Group Ltd. Acquires Ferrari Stainless & Alloys.

    Steel Dynamics Group Ltd. Acquires Ferrari Stainless & Alloys Ltd. Launching P&P Non Ferrous: A Gateway to Enhanced Customer Services and Expansion Down South In a strategic move to bolster its position in the industry, Steel Dynamics Group Ltd. proudly announces the successful acquisition of Ferrari Stainless & Alloys Ltd. in Wimborne. This transformative development…

    Read article →

  • Sustainability is key to modern manufacturing

    Sustainability is key to modern manufacturing

    During my time supplying specialist metals into the manufacturing sector, I have noticed several things regarding the supply chain local to me in South Yorkshire. 1 Large Manufacturing companies often have difficult onboarding processes.  This makes it difficult for smaller SMES or new market entrants to be able to supply them. 2 Manufacturing companies are…

    Read article →

  • Lasers: The Tesla of Tooling

    Lasers: The Tesla of Tooling

    Welcome back, I’m LaserEd, and I work with lasers. I’ll be laser-educating for The Metal Magazine and I hope it results in more metal parts being lasered! First of all, I haven’t had an accident after writing my last article about Laser Safety. I have been busy researching. Although it is time consuming, I love…

    Read article →

  • Implementing QMS Certifications for Small Businesses and Start-Up Companies

    Implementing QMS Certifications for Small Businesses and Start-Up Companies

    Welcome to the fourth and final instalment of this short series on Quality Management System certification for small businesses and start-up companies. In this 4 part series I have been explaining exactly what third-party certification involves, and how you can level up your business through this process. The standard we are focussing on is ISO9001:2015, as…

    Read article →

Get notified when we publish new articles!

Want to feature in the next edition?